Writing a finding someone can act on

A finding is the thing that comes out of security work, and it has to be readable by someone who was not there. This set covers the five parts and their order, why honest severity matters, what a reproduction needs, and why a reader needs a fix as well as a finding.

4 questions 1 task Read the lesson

Questions

Each one is marked as you go, and the explanation arrives straight after, which is the part worth reading.

4 questions, marked as you go.

1 What order do the parts of a finding go in?
2 Why does calling every finding "critical" make a report worse?
3 What should the reproduction part of a finding contain?
4 Why does a reader need a fix as well as a finding?

Tasks

These need your own device. Run the command in Termux, then paste what it printed. The marking looks at what the output means, so spacing, version numbers and ordering do not matter. If you have not installed anything yet, the lesson covers the setup.

Write a finding in the five parts

A finding is a title, what you saw, why it matters, how to reproduce it, and what to do, in that order. This writes a finding about a world readable notes file and reads it back. Notice that the reproduce line names the exact command and the fix line names the exact change.

Run this in Termux On your own device. Nothing on this page executes it. The command runs in your terminal, and this box only reads what you paste back.

mkdir -p ~/findings; printf "title: notes.txt is world readable\nobserved: notes.txt has mode 644, so other apps can read it\nimpact: a private note is exposed to anything with storage access\nreproduce: ls -l ~/findings/notes.txt\nfix: chmod 600 ~/findings/notes.txt\n" > ~/findings/notes-permissions.txt; cat ~/findings/notes-permissions.txt
Marking your own work Both halves of this are checked in your browser, with no server involved, so nothing stops you from pasting output you did not run. The tasks are written so that the easiest way to pass one is to actually do it and read the result, which is the whole intention.

All sets Read the lesson